Two Calm Phrases That Prevent Defensiveness — And Why CEOs Should Use Them in Earnings Calls

Start with a calm fact: why your words on an earnings call move markets — and how two small phrases can stop the reflexive spill

CEOs and CFOs: you know the moment. An analyst asks a pointed question, the room tightens, and an instinctive answer—defensive, off-script, defensive again—gets transcribed, amplified by trading algos and social feeds, and overnight becomes a material market event. In 2026 that chain is shorter and faster than ever: real-time sentiment AI, retail chatrooms, and options flow bots react in seconds. The result? Avoidable volatility, reputational risk, and frustrated investor relations teams.

This guide translates proven negotiation and psychology tools into practical scripting for earnings calls and investor Q&A. You’ll get two calm phrases that neutralize defensiveness, tested templates to insert into live answers, roleplay and compliance steps, and measurable ways to reduce knee-jerk market reactions.

Why defensiveness on earnings calls fuels volatility

From late 2024 through 2026, market microstructure has evolved so that language equals liquidity. A single adjective—"disappointing," "concerning," "optimistic"—can shift sentiment scores used by high-frequency traders and sentiment funds. When executives answer defensively, three things typically happen:

• Emotional language spikes sentiment models: defensive tones trigger negative sentiment classifiers, which feed automated selling signals and amplify dynamic execution.
• Ambiguity breeds speculation: evasive answers force analysts and traders to fill gaps with assumptions, widening bid-ask spreads and option-implied volatility; those predictive holes recall well-documented predictive pitfalls from other domains.
• Media and retail multiply the effect: bite-sized quotes spread on social platforms, each retelling adding noise and accelerating price moves — especially now that instant summarizers and low-latency feeds can prioritize the loudest tokens (AI summarizers are part of the pipeline and can magnify emotional language).

Investor relations (IR) teams already know the downstream cost: increased volatility, more incoming clarification requests, and the need to spend capital on damage control. The fix isn’t long legal statements or tighter non-answers—it's a short change in tone that prevents defensiveness from starting in the first place.

The two calm phrases — simple psychology, big market impact

Derived from evidence-based conflict de-escalation and negotiation research, these two phrases break the automatic defensive loop. They are brief, human, and designed to buy time and reframe the interaction.

Phrase 1: "I understand why you'd ask that" (or "That’s a fair question")

This is an empathy-based opener. It does three things at once:

• Validates the questioner, which reduces perceived threat.
• Signals the speaker is listening, lowering adversarial escalation.
• Creates a short cognitive pause: listeners expect a thoughtful reply, not a reflexive defense.

"I understand why you'd ask that — the market is watching this closely, and we want to be clear."

Phrase 2: "Let me walk you through the facts" (or "Let me explain the data behind that")

This is a fact-framing phrase. After reducing emotional heat, it shifts attention to concrete evidence and process. The goal is to replace speculation with a data-forward narrative.

"Let me walk you through the facts so you can see the drivers behind our guidance."

Together, these phrases form a micro-script: Validate → Pause → Reframe with Data. That structure stops defensiveness from inflating and gives IR teams time to coordinate follow-up (use a private channel or live counsel protocol to avoid mixed messaging — see our playbook on crisis coordination), which in turn reduces ambiguous statements that trigger algorithmic selling.

How and when to use them in an earnings call

Timing and brevity matter. Use the phrases at the first sign of a heated or complex question: anything that touches guidance, regulatory matters, one-off events, or forward-looking assumptions. Below are practical placements and templates.

Placement options

• Immediate opener to a challenging question: uses Phrase 1 to defuse.
• Bridge before a detailed explanation: Phrase 2 moves to data and process (and helps avoid the AI-driven bite-size summaries that often lead headlines — read approaches to automating live workflows).
• As part of a closing promise: combine both to commit to clarifying materials post-call.

Template: Challenging operational question

Analyst: "Can you explain the sudden drop in margin in Q4?"

CEO: "I understand why you'd ask that — it's a fair concern. Let me walk you through the facts: the variance resulted primarily from two timing items (A and B) and a one-time supply adjustment. Our normalized margin outlook for fiscal Q1 excludes these items and is in the materials we’ll post after the call."

Template: Regulatory or legal worry

Analyst: "Are you exposed to the lawsuit mentioned in the press?"

CEO: "That's a fair question. We take these matters seriously. Let me explain what we can share today: the matter relates to X, we've engaged counsel, and based on current information we do not expect a material impact to revenue. We'll update you as material facts change and provide a written summary to IR after this call."

Template: Guidance surprise

Analyst: "Why is guidance lower than expectations?"

CEO: "I understand why you’d ask — guidance is the focal point for many investors. Let me walk you through the elements: reduced demand in segment Y, timing of large orders, and FX impacts. We also want to be conservative after the inventory disruption; we’ll lay out the scenario analysis in the deck posted after the call."

Why these scripts reduce market reaction — the mechanics

There are measurable pathways by which calm phrasing reduces volatility:

• Lower negative sentiment scores: validating language and evidence-based follow-ups yield fewer negative sentiment tokens for NLP models, reducing the chance that automated systems surface alarmist soundbites (see how AI pipelines can compound tone).
• Fewer ambiguous soundbites: the combination of pause and data reduces the number of quoteable, sensational fragments.
• Controlled information flow: promising and delivering a structured follow-up gives traders a clear time horizon for additional data, which often compresses speculative trades — this intersects with research on controlled information registries and how trust layers shape market reactions.

In practice, companies that adopted micro-scripting and post-call briefings in late 2025 reported narrower post-earnings realized volatility and lower option-implied volatility spikes in the 24-hour window after calls. While results vary, the directional effect is consistent: calm language buys you measurable time and reduces knee-jerk moves.

Do's and don'ts for CEOs and IR teams

Do

• Do keep phrases short and authentic — rehearsed, not robotic.
• Do align with legal and compliance language ahead of the call.
• Do train for follow-up: have the data slide and IR note ready to post within minutes.
• Do use the phrases proactively for questions you know will come up.
• Do record and analyze sentiment and volatility metrics after each call.

Don't

• Don't use empathy phrases as filler before a non-answer; that backfires.
• Don't over-explain in the room; a compact data-forward reply plus a promise to follow up is more effective.
• Don't let legal override clarity — pre-plan what can and can’t be said so answers stay calm and precise.

Advanced scripting: building a 30-second safe-response framework

For fast-moving calls, use a micro-framework that fits into 30–45 seconds. Practice it until it feels natural.

1. Open with Phrase 1: "That’s a fair question." (2–3 seconds)
2. Pause for one breath: (1–2 seconds) — let the validation land.
3. Deliver a 20–30 second evidence snapshot using Phrase 2: "Let me walk you through the facts — we saw X due to A, B, C."
4. Close with the follow-up promise: "IR will post the detailed analysis on our site in 30 minutes; we’ll also host a follow-up call if you want more color." (3–5 seconds)

Example in practice:

Analyst: "How confident are you in the supply recovery timeline?"

CEO: "That’s a fair question. Let me walk you through the facts: our logistics partners have brought capacity back to 85% of peak levels, key parts deliveries are tracking to the revised plan, and we’ve built a buffer for Q1. IR will post the recovery timeline and assumptions in the next 30 minutes."

Operationalizing the approach: IR playbook and training

Turn the phrases into operational muscle by embedding them into your IR playbook.

• Script bank: Maintain 10–15 micro-scripts for likely high-risk topics (guidance, regulation, supply, M&A rumors, crypto exposures, ESG). Include both the calm opener and the factual bridge.
• Roleplay sessions: Monthly rehearsals for executives with IR, legal, and a simulated market-response team that includes a trader role and a social media moderator.
• Rapid post-call content: Pre-approved one-pagers for the top 5 risk topics to post within 30–60 minutes of the call.
• Live counsel protocol: A private channel connecting the CEO, CFO, General Counsel, and IR lead during the Q&A to coordinate statements — think of it like an incident-response channel used in other critical public-sector workflows (incident-response playbooks).

Measuring success: KPIs that matter

Don’t guess — measure. Useful KPIs to track after each earnings event include:

• Intraday realized volatility: Compare the first two hours after the call to a historical baseline.
• Option implied vol changes: Spike in IV often signals uncertainty—track it on overnight options.
• Sentiment delta: NLP sentiment scores for the call transcript versus prior calls.
• Clarification requests: Number of follow-up calls/emails to IR in the 24-hour window.
• Social volume: Mentions and sentiment on major platforms and investor forums.

Over repeated calls, a firm can benchmark improvements and attribute changes to scripting, training, or other interventions.

2026 trends that make calm scripting critical

Three developments in 2025–2026 amplify the need for micro-scripting:

• Real-time sentiment feed proliferation: Hedge funds and retail platforms now integrate live sentiment scores into execution strategies. Calm phrasing lowers the probability of triggering those automated responses.
• AI-driven bite-size summarizers: Apps summarize calls instantly; short, empathetic phrases stop those summaries from starting with negative framing.
• Regulatory spotlight on transparency: Regulators are scrutinizing forward-looking statements and disclosure practices more closely. A calm, data-forward approach aligns with both transparency and legal prudence.

Real-world case study (anonymized)

In late 2025, a mid-cap tech company faced outsized post-earnings volatility after an executive used an off-script, emotionally defensive reply about churn. The stock fell 8% intraday and implied volatility jumped 15%. The IR team restructured the next call using the two-phrase approach, pre-posting a one-page fact sheet and roleplaying tougher scenarios. Result: the subsequent call saw a 40% reduction in intraday volatility and fewer clarification requests. Traders reported the call as "calmer," and social sentiment was more neutral in automated summaries.

Common objections and how to counter them

Objection: "Won't these phrases sound contrived?" — They can if overused. The trick is to rehearse them until they’re natural and to follow them immediately with tangible facts; authenticity comes from substance, not novelty.

Objection: "Legal won't allow these promises." — Work with legal to pre-approve the language and the post-call materials. The phrases are deliberately high-level; the substance comes from the data you control.

Objection: "We can't prepare for every question." — You can't, but you can prepare for the categories that drive the most volatility: guidance, regulatory risk, one-offs, and major operational shifts.

Quick-reference script cheat sheet

• Opening validation: "That’s a fair question."
• Data bridge: "Let me walk you through the facts..."
• Short evidence snapshot: "...we saw X for reasons A, B, C."
• Close & follow-up: "IR will post the detailed analysis in X minutes and follow up with any material updates."

Final takeaways: what to do next

Defensiveness is adaptive in relationships—and on earnings calls it’s costly. Two small, well-placed phrases stop the reflex, buy you time, and steer the conversation back to evidence. For 2026 market dynamics, that brief pause is now one of the highest-leverage moves a CEO or CFO can make to protect value and preserve credibility.

Action plan for this quarter:

1. Embed the two calm phrases into your IR playbook and pre-approve them with legal.
2. Run at least two roleplay sessions before the next earnings call, including a social/trading simulation.
3. Prepare and pre-format one-page post-call clarifications for your top five risk topics.
4. Track the KPIs listed here and compare them across calls to quantify impact.

Call to action

If you lead investor relations or sit at the executive table, don’t wait for the next volatility episode. Download our ready-to-use earnings Q&A script pack and join a live workshop where we run mock calls against simulated market reactions. Sign up for Fool.Live's executive IR newsletter for the latest templates, case studies, and 2026-specific strategies to keep your call calm and your stock stable.

Related Reading

• Microcap Momentum and Retail Signals: Advanced Market Structure Implications for 2026
• Interoperable Verification Layer: A Consortium Roadmap for Trust & Scalability in 2026
• Live Drops & Low-Latency Streams: The Creator Playbook for 2026
• 6 Ways to Stop Cleaning Up After AI: Concrete Data Engineering Patterns
• How AI Nearshore Teams Can Transform Maintenance Scheduling and Tenant Support
• Basal Body Temp vs Skin Temp: Which Is Better for Tracking Fertility—and What That Means for Beauty Wearables
• Building a Rights-First Workflow Before Uploading to AI Video Startups
• Storage Optimization Tactics for Retailers Facing Rising SSD Costs
• Must-Read Mac mini M4 Deal Guide: Is the $100 Off Price the Real Bargain? (And How to Save More on Flipkart)